St. John's Water Dog vs Smithfield
St. John's Water Dog
Working
The St. John's Water Dog, an ancestor of modern retrievers, was a loyal and intelligent breed known for its swimming abilities and strong work ethic. Though extinct, its legacy lives on in today's retriever breeds.
Smithfield
Herding
The Smithfield is a loyal and intelligent herding breed, known for its affectionate nature and adaptability as a family companion.
At a Glance
| St. John's Water Dog | Category | Smithfield |
|---|---|---|
| Working | Breed Group | Herding |
| Newfoundland, Canada | Origin | England |
| 51–61 cm | Height | 46–56 cm |
| 23–32 kg | Weight | 18–27 kg |
| 10 - 12 years | Lifespan | 12 - 15 years |
| 60 min/day | Exercise | 90 min/day |
| Double | Coat Type | Double |
| Short | Coat Length | Medium |
Ratings Comparison
| St. John's Water Dog | Trait | Smithfield |
|---|---|---|
High | Energy Level | High |
High | Trainability | High |
Very High | Affection | Very High |
Very High | Intelligence | Very High |
Moderate | Shedding | Moderate |
High | Grooming Ease | Moderate |
Low | Barking | Moderate |
Very High | Good w/ Kids | Very High |
High | Good w/ Pets | High |
Moderate | Apartment | Moderate |
Very High | Families | Very High |
High | First-Time Owners | High |
High | Playfulness | High |
Very Low | Drooling | Low |
St. John's Water Dog vs Smithfield FAQ
Is a St. John's Water Dog or Smithfield better for families?+
Both the St. John's Water Dog and Smithfield rate equally well for families with a score of 5/5.
Which is easier to train, a St. John's Water Dog or Smithfield?+
Both breeds score 4/5 for trainability, making them equally easy to train.
Does a St. John's Water Dog or Smithfield shed more?+
The St. John's Water Dog has a shedding level of 3/5, while the Smithfield scores 3/5. They shed about the same amount.
Does a St. John's Water Dog or Smithfield need more exercise?+
The St. John's Water Dog needs about 60 minutes of daily exercise, while the Smithfield requires around 90 minutes. The Smithfield is the more active breed.
Which lives longer, a St. John's Water Dog or Smithfield?+
The St. John's Water Dog has an average lifespan of 10 - 12 years, while the Smithfield lives approximately 12 - 15 years.
Which is better for apartment living, a St. John's Water Dog or Smithfield?+
Both breeds score 3/5 for apartment suitability.